We Wanted Our Babies to Be Biologically Related, but Our Genetic Screening Revealed Something Neither of Us Expected

Like Sisters

Part One: The House Next Door

My name is Sarah Lindell. I’m thirty-two years old.

I never expected the happiest chapter of my life to lead to a medical appointment that would leave me terrified for my unborn child.

And I never expected that appointment to answer a question I didn’t even know I’d been asking my whole life.

My best friend, Emily Carver, is thirty-one.

We’ve been inseparable for twenty-five years.

We grew up in neighboring houses on Sycamore Lane in Westbrook, Ohio. A small town east of Columbus with one high school, one Dairy Queen, and a water tower painted like a giant baseball.

My house was yellow with white shutters. Hers was blue with a red door. There was a gap in the hedge between our backyards that our fathers never fixed, because by the time they noticed it, we’d worn a dirt path through it.

We met when I was seven and she was six.

She was sitting on her back steps crying because her goldfish had died. I came through the hedge with a shoebox and a garden trowel and said, “We should have a funeral.”

We buried him under her mother’s rose bush. I said a prayer. She sang “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” because it was the only song she knew all the words to.

After that, we were never apart.

We attended the same schools. Westbrook Elementary, Westbrook Middle, Westbrook High.

We shared countless adventures. Building forts in the woods behind the Methodist church. Sneaking into the community pool after closing. Driving to Columbus at sixteen to see a concert we’d lied to our parents about.

We supported each other through our first crushes, our first kisses, our first heartbreaks. When Tommy Reinhart dumped me at the junior prom, Emily poured a cup of red punch down the back of his tuxedo.

When Emily’s father had his heart attack our senior year, I slept on her bedroom floor for two weeks.

Our mothers frequently joked that we behaved more like sisters than best friends.

“Look at you two,” my mother, Marie, would say. Watching us lie on the trampoline in the backyard, finishing each other’s sentences. “Peas in a pod.”

“Same nose,” Emily’s mother, Barbara, would say. Laughing. “Same stubborn chin. Are you sure the hospital didn’t mix them up?”

They’d laugh.

Then sometimes they’d look at each other.

And stop laughing.

I never thought anything of it.

Part Two: The Dream

For as long as I can remember, Emily and I shared one particular dream.

We wanted to become mothers. And watch our children grow up together.

We planned it when we were ten. Lying in a tent in my backyard with flashlights.

We’d live next door to each other. Our kids would cut through a hedge. They’d have a dirt path. They’d bury goldfish together and pour punch on boys who were mean to them.

“Pinky swear,” Emily said.

“Pinky swear,” I said.

Unfortunately, life didn’t unfold the way we’d imagined.

I married a man named Kevin when I was twenty-four. He was charming and funny and sold medical devices. We bought a little house in Columbus. We tried to have a baby.

Two years later, I found out he’d been having an affair with a woman from his office.

My marriage ended five years ago. It left me heartbroken and uncertain about my future. I moved back to Westbrook. I rented a small house three blocks from Sycamore Lane.

I’m a pediatric nurse at the children’s hospital in Columbus. I take care of other people’s babies all day.

Emily never married.

She had several serious relationships. A teacher. A firefighter. A sweet, quiet man named Paul she dated for four years, who left because he didn’t want children.

She’s a librarian at the Westbrook Public Library. The children’s section. She does story time on Tuesday and Thursday mornings with a puppet named Mr. Biscuit.

By the time we reached our thirties, we’d both grown tired of waiting for the right partners.

Part Three: The Idea

Then, one evening, Emily suggested something completely unexpected.

It was a Friday night in October. We were sitting on my back porch with a bottle of wine and a bag of Doritos. It was cold. We had blankets over our legs.

We’d been talking about babies. Again. Like always.

“Sarah,” Emily said. “What if our children weren’t simply childhood friends?”

I smiled.

“What do you mean?”

She leaned forward. She had that look. The one she used to get when she wanted to sneak into the community pool.

“What if they actually shared the same biological father?” she said. “They could be brother and sister. Or two sisters. Or two brothers.”

She grinned.

“Real siblings,” she said. “Not just like siblings.”

At first, I thought she was joking.

But Emily had already considered the possibilities.

She’d been researching for months. She pulled out her phone and showed me. Fertility clinics in Columbus. Sperm banks. Donor profiles. Success rates. Costs.

We could both become mothers through fertility treatment, she said. Using sperm from the same donor.

Our children would share a biological connection. Half-siblings.

And we could raise them together. Next door. Just like we’d always hoped.

“Emily,” I said. “That’s crazy.”

“I know,” she said.

“Like, really crazy.”

“I know,” she said. “But think about it.”

The idea was unconventional.

But it gradually began to make sense.

Part Four: Daniel

After months of consultations, medical examinations, and careful discussions, we chose a fertility clinic.

The Columbus Reproductive Health Center. A big modern building on the north side of the city with glass walls and a fountain in the lobby.

They worked with a sperm bank called Heritage Cryobank. One of the oldest in Ohio. Founded in 1981.

We spent three weekends at Emily’s kitchen table, scrolling through donor profiles on her laptop.

Height. Weight. Eye color. Hair color. Education. Medical history. A short essay from each donor about why he’d decided to donate.

We selected a donor named Daniel.

That wasn’t his real name. The bank used first names only. Donor #4471, “Daniel.”

According to the profile, he was thirty-five. Six feet tall. Brown hair, hazel eyes. A PhD in biochemistry. He’d donated in graduate school, in 2014.

He’d passed every required medical screening. Genetic carrier testing for cystic fibrosis, spinal muscular atrophy, Tay-Sachs, and two hundred other conditions. All negative.

His essay was what sold us.

I was raised by a single mother, he wrote. I never knew my father. She told me he was a good man who couldn’t be there. I’m donating because I want to help people build families. Families come in all shapes. Mine was just me and my mom. And it was enough.

“He sounds kind,” Emily said.

“He sounds like us,” I said.

We completed the procedures in January.

Both of us. Same week. Same clinic. Same doctor.

And then we waited.

Part Five: Two Pink Lines

Then something wonderful happened.

I became pregnant.

I found out on a Tuesday morning in February. I took the test in my bathroom at six a.m. before my shift at the hospital. I sat on the edge of the tub and stared at those two pink lines until my alarm went off.

Then I called Emily.

She screamed so loud I had to hold the phone away from my ear.

Three weeks later, Emily discovered she was expecting too.

She showed up at my front door at eleven o’clock at night in her pajamas. Holding the test in her hand. Crying.

We stood in my doorway hugging for ten minutes.

We were overwhelmed with happiness.

We bought tiny baby clothes. A matching pair of onesies that said BEST FRIENDS and BEFORE WE WERE BORN.

We compared ultrasound pictures. We had our appointments on the same days, back to back, so we could go together.

We discussed names. Hundreds of names. We made lists on the refrigerator.

We imagined our children celebrating birthdays together. Cutting through a hedge. Burying goldfish.

For the first time in years, everything seemed to be falling into place.

Part Six: The Call

But during the fifth month of our pregnancies, our excitement turned into fear.

At twenty weeks, the clinic recommended an expanded genetic screening.

It’s a newer test. More detailed than the standard ones. They draw your blood and look at the baby’s DNA floating in it. It can find chromosomal problems and some genetic conditions.

It can also show things you weren’t looking for.

We both had our blood drawn on the same day. In early June.

Two weeks later, one morning, the genetics clinic called.

I was at work. On the pediatric floor. Changing an IV bag for a four-year-old with pneumonia.

My phone buzzed in my scrub pocket. I didn’t recognize the number.

I answered in the hallway.

“Sarah Lindell?”

“Yes?”

“This is Rachel. I’m a nurse with the Genetics Center at Ohio State. Dr. Harrison needs to speak with you and Emily Carver as soon as possible.”

Something in her voice immediately worried me.

I’ve been a nurse for ten years. I know that voice. I’ve used that voice.

“Is there a problem with our babies?” I asked.

Rachel hesitated.

“Please come to the clinic,” she said. “The doctor will explain everything.”

“When?”

“Today,” she said. “If you can. Three o’clock.”

I called Emily immediately.

She was at the library. In the middle of story time. I could hear the kids singing in the background.

“Em,” I said. “We need to go to the genetics clinic. Today. At three.”

There was a long pause.

“Both of us?” she said.

“Both of us.”

Part Seven: Dr. Harrison

Neither of us said much during the drive.

Forty minutes from Westbrook to Columbus. I drove. Emily sat in the passenger seat with both hands on her belly, looking out the window at the cornfields.

At one point, she reached over and took my hand.

She didn’t let go until we parked.

The Genetics Center is on the fourth floor of a medical building at Ohio State. A quiet waiting room with soft chairs and a fish tank and framed pictures of DNA helixes on the walls.

Rachel came to get us. She took us down a long hallway to a corner office.

When we entered Dr. Harrison’s office, he was studying two genetic reports.

They were displayed side by side on two computer monitors on his desk. Columns of numbers and letters and colored bars.

He was in his sixties. Gray hair. Wire glasses. A kind face.

He didn’t greet us with his usual reassuring smile.

Instead, he examined the results again.

Then he got up, walked past us, and slowly closed the office door.

He sat back down.

He looked at both of us.

“Before we discuss these findings,” he said, “I need to confirm something.”

Emily gripped my hand.

“What is it, Doctor?” she said.

“Are you absolutely certain,” Dr. Harrison said, “that the same sperm donor was used for both pregnancies?”

“Yes,” we answered together.

“Donor 4471,” I said. “Daniel. From Heritage Cryobank.”

He nodded slowly.

He looked at the screens once more.

His expression grew increasingly serious.

“The genetic similarities between your babies,” he said, “are not entirely what we expected.”

I felt my heartbeat quicken.

“But they share the same biological father,” Emily said. “Wouldn’t that explain the similarities?”

“It would explain some of them,” Dr. Harrison said carefully.

He pointed at the screens.

“Half-siblings share about twenty-five percent of their DNA,” he said. “That’s what we’d expect between your babies.”

He paused.

“These two fetuses,” he said, “share closer to thirty-seven percent.”

I stared at the numbers on the screen. I didn’t understand them.

But I understood the look on his face.

“These preliminary findings,” Dr. Harrison said, “suggest there may be another biological connection we haven’t accounted for.”

I instinctively placed my hands over my stomach.

“Doctor, please tell us,” I said. “Are our babies sick?”

He looked at me. Then at Emily.

“We haven’t established that either child has a medical condition,” he said. “Further testing is necessary.”

He paused before continuing.

“I’ve worked in this field for twenty-seven years,” he said. “I’ve rarely encountered a situation like this.”

He folded his hands on the desk.

“If these results are confirmed,” he said, “there is something extremely important you both need to understand. About your children’s biological relationships. And possible medical risks.”

Emily’s hand tightened around mine.

“Then tell us,” she whispered.

Dr. Harrison took a slow breath.

“First,” he said, “I need to ask you both a question about your families.”

I stared at him.

“What question?”

He looked directly into my eyes.

“Sarah,” he said. “Emily.”

He paused.

“Are you absolutely certain,” he said, “that the two of you aren’t biologically related?”

Part Eight: The Question

For several seconds, neither of us could speak.

Are you absolutely certain the two of you aren’t biologically related?

I looked at Emily.

She looked at me.

Same nose.

Same stubborn chin.

Are you sure the hospital didn’t mix them up?

“That’s—” Emily started. “That’s impossible. We’re not related. We met when I was six. Over a dead goldfish.”

“Our parents are completely different people,” I said. “My dad was Swedish. From Minnesota. Her dad’s family is Irish. From Boston.”

Dr. Harrison nodded slowly.

“I understand,” he said. “And I’m not saying you are. I’m saying the numbers suggest it.”

He pointed to a colored bar on one of the screens.

“If two mothers are unrelated,” he said, “and they use the same donor, their babies share about twenty-five percent of their DNA. Through the father.”

He pointed to another number.

“If the two mothers are themselves half-sisters,” he said, “the babies would share more. About thirty-seven percent. Through the father and through the mothers.”

We Wanted Our Babies to Be Biologically Related, but Our Genetic Screening Revealed Something Neither of Us Expected

He looked at us.

“That’s what these numbers show,” he said.

“Half-sisters,” I repeated.

“There’s something else,” Dr. Harrison said.

Part Nine: Runs of Homozygosity

He pulled up a different screen.

A long graph. Colored bars. Some of them highlighted in red.

“These are called runs of homozygosity,” he said. “Long stretches of DNA where a baby inherited the exact same sequence from both parents.”

He pointed.

“Every person has a few,” he said. “Short ones. It’s normal.”

He pointed at the red bars.

“These are long,” he said. “Longer than we’d expect from two unrelated parents.”

He looked at both of us.

“Both of your babies show this pattern,” he said. “To a similar degree.”

“What does that mean?” I asked. My voice was barely a whisper.

Dr. Harrison took off his glasses.

“It means,” he said carefully, “that in addition to the two of you possibly being related to each other, there may also be a biological relationship between each of you and the donor.”

The room went completely silent.

“Between us,” Emily said slowly, “and Daniel.”

“Yes,” Dr. Harrison said.

“What kind of relationship?” I asked.

He was quiet for a long moment.

“The pattern is consistent,” he said, “with the mother and the donor being half-siblings.”

I couldn’t breathe.

“That’s not possible,” Emily said. “We don’t know him. We don’t even know his real name. He’s an anonymous donor from a sperm bank.”

“I know,” Dr. Harrison said gently.

He put his glasses back on.

“That’s why I asked about your families,” he said.

Part Ten: The Risks

He explained the risks.

Slowly. Carefully. The way I explain things to frightened parents at the hospital.

When two parents are closely related, he said, their child has a higher chance of inheriting two copies of the same rare recessive gene. One from each parent.

Most of the time, that’s harmless.

Sometimes, it causes a genetic condition.

“For children of unrelated parents,” Dr. Harrison said, “the background risk of a serious birth defect or genetic disorder is about three to four percent.”

He paused.

“For children of half-siblings,” he said, “it’s higher. Studies vary. Maybe six to nine percent.”

“So there’s a ninety percent chance they’re fine,” Emily said.

“Roughly,” Dr. Harrison said. “Yes.”

He looked at her.

“But I can’t tell you which group your baby is in,” he said. “Not yet. Not without more testing.”

He recommended an amniocentesis. For both of us. And whole-exome sequencing. A test that looks at every gene in the baby’s DNA.

It would take three weeks to get the results.

He also recommended something else.

“You need to talk to your mothers,” he said.

Part Eleven: The Drive Home

We sat in my car in the parking garage for an hour.

Neither of us said anything for a long time.

Then Emily laughed.

A strange, broken laugh.

“Same nose,” she said. “Same stubborn chin.”

She put her face in her hands.

“Our mothers used to joke about it,” she said. “Every single week.”

“And then they’d stop laughing,” I said quietly.

Emily looked at me.

“You noticed that too?” she said.

“Every time,” I said.

“Sarah,” she said. “What if it’s true?”

I looked out the windshield at the concrete wall of the parking garage.

“Then we’ve been sisters for twenty-five years,” I said. “And didn’t know it.”

Emily reached over and took my hand.

“We always knew it,” she said.

Part Twelve: Two Mothers

We went to see our mothers that night.

Together.

My mother, Marie, still lives in the yellow house on Sycamore Lane. She’s sixty-five. My dad, Erik, died of a stroke six years ago.

Emily’s mother, Barbara, still lives in the blue house next door. She’s sixty-four. Emily’s dad, Mike, is sixty-seven. Retired from the post office. Still alive. Still fixing things in his garage.

We knocked on my mother’s door at seven o’clock.

She opened it in her apron. She’d been baking. She saw our faces.

She stopped smiling.

“Mom,” I said. “Can you call Barbara? We need to talk to both of you.”

My mother looked at me for a long time.

Then she looked at Emily.

Then she took off her apron.

“I’ll call her,” she said quietly.

Barbara came through the hedge. The same gap our fathers never fixed. The same dirt path Emily and I wore down when we were little.

She came into my mother’s kitchen. She sat down at the table.

The two of them sat side by side. Two women in their sixties who’d been next-door neighbors for thirty-two years.

I set the genetics reports on the kitchen table.

“Dr. Harrison asked us a question today,” I said. “At the genetics clinic.”

My voice was shaking.

“He asked if Emily and I are biologically related,” I said.

My mother put her hand over her mouth.

Barbara closed her eyes.

Neither of them said That’s ridiculous.

Neither of them said Of course not.

They looked at each other.

Part Thirteen: 1993

It was Barbara who spoke first.

“Your father couldn’t have children,” she said to Emily.

Emily stared at her.

“Mike had the mumps,” Barbara said. “When he was nineteen. It made him sterile. We didn’t find out until we’d been trying for three years.”

She looked at her hands.

“He was so ashamed,” she said. “He made me promise never to tell anyone. Not his family. Not you.”

Then my mother spoke.

“Your father had a low sperm count,” she said to me. “Almost none. The doctors said we’d never conceive naturally.”

She looked at me.

“Erik was devastated,” she said. “He was so proud. He made me swear the same thing.”

“So we went to a fertility clinic,” Barbara said.

“In Columbus,” my mother said.

They looked at each other.

“Dr. Gerald Whitcomb,” Barbara said quietly. “The Whitcomb Fertility Clinic. On High Street.”

“He was the best,” my mother said. “Everybody said so. He’d helped hundreds of women.”

“He told us he used donor sperm from medical students,” Barbara said. “Anonymous. Screened. Healthy. Young men from Ohio State.”

“He said the donors were matched to our husbands,” my mother said. “Same coloring. Same build. So no one would ever know.”

I went in March of 1993,” Barbara said. “Emily was born in December.”

“I went in April of 1992,” my mother said. “Sarah was born in January of 1993.”

Emily and I looked at each other.

“We didn’t know,” my mother said. “We didn’t know about each other.”

She looked at Barbara.

“We’d just moved here,” she said. “Erik got a job at the Honda plant in Marysville. We bought the yellow house in 1992.”

“We moved in next door in 1993,” Barbara said. “Mike got transferred to the Westbrook post office.”

“It was years before we figured it out,” Barbara said.

Part Fourteen: The Hedge

“How?” I asked.

My mother was quiet for a long moment.

“You and Emily,” she said. “When you were eight and seven. You were playing in the backyard. Running through the sprinkler.”

She smiled sadly.

“You both had the same birthmark,” she said. “A little brown spot behind your left knee. The exact same shape. Like a little bean.”

I looked at Emily.

I have that birthmark. Behind my left knee.

Emily has it too.

We used to call them our twin beans.

“I mentioned it to Barbara,” my mother said. “Laughing. Over the hedge. I said, Look, they even have the same birthmark.”

She looked at Barbara.

“And Barbara got very quiet,” my mother said.

“That night,” Barbara said, “I came through the hedge. After the girls were asleep. I knocked on Marie’s back door.”

She looked at my mother.

“I asked her if she’d ever been to Dr. Whitcomb,” Barbara said.

“I almost fainted,” my mother said.

“We sat at this kitchen table until two in the morning,” Barbara said. “With a bottle of wine. Figuring it out.”

She looked at us.

“Dr. Whitcomb told both of us we were getting sperm from a medical student,” she said. “Both of us. The same year. And our daughters had the same birthmark and the same nose and the same chin.”

“We didn’t know for sure,” my mother said. “There were no DNA tests back then. Not like now.”

“But we knew,” Barbara said quietly.

“Why didn’t you tell us?” Emily asked.

Her voice was shaking.

The two women looked at each other.

“Because of your fathers,” my mother said.

“They never knew about each other,” Barbara said. “Erik didn’t know Mike had been to Dr. Whitcomb. Mike didn’t know about Erik.”

“And they’d made us promise,” my mother said. “Never to tell anyone. Ever.”

“And because of you two,” Barbara said.

She looked at Emily and me.

“You loved each other so much,” she said. “You were so happy. Running through that hedge. Burying goldfish. Pinky swearing in tents.”

She wiped her eyes.

“We didn’t want to take that away,” she said. “We didn’t want to make it complicated. We thought, What difference does it make? They’re already sisters.”

“So we kept the secret,” my mother said. “For twenty-four years.”

Part Fifteen: The Donor

“Mom,” I said. “There’s more.”

I told them about the runs of homozygosity. The red bars on Dr. Harrison’s screen.

The pattern that suggested each of us was also related to the donor.

My mother went white.

“Daniel,” she said. “The donor’s name is Daniel?”

“That’s what the bank calls him,” I said. “Donor 4471. He’s thirty-five. A biochemist. He was raised by a single mother. He never knew his father.”

Barbara put both hands flat on the kitchen table.

“Heritage Cryobank,” she said. “In Columbus.”

“Yes,” Emily said.

Barbara looked at my mother.

“Marie,” she said. “When was Heritage founded?”

My mother shook her head.

“I don’t know.”

I pulled out my phone. I looked it up.

Heritage Cryobank. Founded 1981 by Dr. Gerald Whitcomb, M.D.

The kitchen went silent.

Part Sixteen: The Most Shocking Discovery

It took six weeks to confirm everything.

Emily and I both did a DNA test. One of those home kits. Spit in a tube. Mail it in.

We took the tests the same night. At my kitchen table. With the genetics reports and a box of Kleenex.

The results came back on a Thursday in August.

Same day. Ten minutes apart.

At the top of my DNA Relatives list, there was one name.

Emily Carver. Predicted relationship: Half-sister. Shared DNA: 24.8%.

At the top of Emily’s list, my name.

Sarah Lindell. Half-sister.

And below that, on both of our lists, there were more.

So many more.

Jennifer Mattox. Half-sibling.

Brian Okafor. Half-sibling.

Laura Delancey. Half-sibling.

Matthew Pruitt. Half-sibling.

Forty-three of them.

Forty-three half-siblings. Born between 1979 and 1997. Most of them in Ohio. All of them conceived at the Whitcomb Fertility Clinic on High Street in Columbus.

All of them sharing about twenty-five percent of their DNA with each other.

And one more.

Daniel Whitcomb. Half-sibling. Shared DNA: 25.3%.

Part Seventeen: Daniel Whitcomb

His name was Daniel Whitcomb.

He was thirty-five. A research biochemist at a pharmaceutical company in Indianapolis.

He was Dr. Gerald Whitcomb’s son.

Not his legitimate son.

Dr. Whitcomb had been married for forty years. He had three children with his wife. Daniel wasn’t one of them.

Daniel’s mother was a nurse who’d worked at the Whitcomb Fertility Clinic in the late 1980s. A single woman wh…

Related Articles

Back to top button